Pentagon Panel Has Contractor Contacts: Analysis finds financial ties
More than half of the panel members appointed to review the Pentagon’s latest four-year strategy blueprint have financial ties to defense contractors with a stake in the planning process, a USA TODAY analysis shows.
Congress created the 20-member panel in 2006 to analyze the Defense Department’s four-year plan, known as the Quadrennial Defense Review. Lawmakers called for the committee to provide an independent “alternate view” of the Pentagon’s plan, which shapes future military policy and spending on weapons and other needs.
A dozen of the unpaid panelists were appointed by Defense Secretary Robert Gates and eight by the top Republican and Democrat members of the House and Senate Armed Services committees. Eleven work for defense contractors as employees, consultants or board directors, records show.
“The Pentagon often talks about its cooperation with industry, but this makes you wonder who’s wearing the pants in this relationship,” said Mandy Smithberger, national security investigator for the Project on Government Oversight.
Gates “takes very seriously” the ethical issues confronting panelists with ties to defense firms, said Paul Hughes of the U.S. Institute of Peace, the QDR committee’s executive director. Last fall, the secretary ordered that his appointees be covered by federal ethics rules and had to disclose their assets and sources of income, Hughes said.
Initially, according to panelist John Lehman, congressional appointees were not to be subject to the executive branch ethics and disclosure rules.
This week, after inquiries by USA TODAY, officials from the Pentagon and Congress decided that all panel members will be governed by the same rules, Hughes said. The panelists have agreed to recuse themselves from considering any recommendation that could affect a company with which they are affiliated.
Committee members will have to file financial disclosure statements to the Pentagon, but those disclosures won’t be publicly available, said Cynthia Smith, a Defense Department spokeswoman.
One case that will require a recusal involves panelist Lehman, a former Navy secretary in the Reagan administration who was appointed to the committee by Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the ranking Republican on the Armed Services panel. Lehman runs an investment company specializing in defense holdings. His firm owns Atlantic Marine Holding Co., which repairs Navy ships in Mayport, Fla. The latest version of the review, released last week, recommends moving a nuclear aircraft carrier to Mayport from Norfolk, Va., which could mean more business for Atlantic Marine.
Lehman said he would recuse himself from reviewing the Mayport carrier issue and anything else that touched on his business interests. At the same time, he said, he and others with defense ties are capable of offering unbiased advice. Most defense experts have some financial affiliation with the defense industry, Lehman said, pointing out that the Defense Department does business with more than 33,000 companies and also funds university research.
“Could you find anybody who knows anything about defense who doesn’t have some potential conflict of interest?” he asked.
Some experts say the answer is yes. “There are retired military officers or Defense officials who don’t have defense industry ties. If you wanted to find these people, you could,” said Jordan Tama, an American University professor and expert on government commissions.
Review panel members
The members of the independent panel appointed to study the Quadrennial Defense Review include the panel’s co-chairmen: Former Defense secretary William Perry and former National Security adviser Stephen Hadley each work for the defense industry. Perry is chairman of the board of LGS Innovations, a division of Alcatel Lucent, which won nearly $70 million in defense contracts last year, and Hadley is on the board of Raytheon, which won more than $15.8 billion, according to government contracting data. Neither responded to requests for comment.
Other members of the panel with defense ties:
- Richard Armitage: Member, board of directors, ManTech International. Appointed by Defense Secretary Robert Gates.
- J.D. Crouch: Head of technology solutions group, QinetiQ. Appointed by Gates.
- Joan Dempsey: Senior vice president, Booz Allen Hamilton. Appointed by Gates.
- David Jeremiah: Member, board of directors, ManTech International; chairman, Wackenhut Services; chairman, Technology Strategies & Alliances, a consulting firm with defense contractors as clients. Appointed by Gates.
- George Joulwan: Member, board of directors, General Dynamics. Appointed by Gates.
- Alice Maroni: Member, board of trustees, LMI Government Consulting, which provides consulting services for the military. Appointed by Gates.
- Jack Keane: Member, board of directors, General Dynamics; adviser to chairman, URS Corp.; chairman, Keane Advisors, a consulting firm with defense contractors as clients. Appointed by Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz.
- John Lehman: Chairman, J.F. Lehman & Company, a private equity firm that owns defense contractors; member, board of directors, Ball Corp., and EnerSys. Appointed by McCain.
- Robert Scales: Chairman, Colgen LP, a consulting firm with defense contractors as clients. Appointed by Rep. Ike Skelton, D-Mo.
Other members of the review panel:
- Rudy deLeon: Former Defense official, now senior vice president at Center for American Progress. Appointed by Gates.
- Sherri Goodman: Former Defense official, now senior vice president at the Center for Naval Analyses. Appointed by Gates.
- Paul Van Riper: Retired Marine lieutenant general. Appointed by Gates.
- Larry Welch: Retired Air Force general and former head of the Institute for Defense Analyses. Appointed by Gates.
- Charles Curtis: President emeritus of the Nuclear Threat Initiative. Appointed by Sen. Carl Levin, D-Mich.
- Eric Edelman: Former ambassador and Defense official, fellow at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments. Appointed by Rep. Buck McKeon, R-Calif.
- Richard Kohn: University of North Carolina professor of history and peace, war and defense. Appointed by Skelton.
- John Nagl: Retired Army lieutenant colonel and president of the Center for a New American Security. Appointed by Levin.
- James Talent: Republican former senator from Missouri and fellow at the Heritage Foundation. Appointed by McKeon.
By Ray Locker and Ken Dilanian, USA Today